The boat has a slow transom leak (above the drain plug). The bilge pump situation has improved: the original Rule-Mate 500 is working again (auto sensing + pumping), so there's a functioning automatic bilge (no longer the manual-every-few-hours situation). The second pump runs but won't move water (under inspection); a new pump arrives tonight.
Make it bulletproof + fix the leak: keep the working auto pump + add the new pump as a backup on its own higher float + a high-water alarm + keep the battery charged; then plan the leak's real fix at a haul-out. A boat with a known leak shouldn't lean on a single pump. Details: transom leak · bilge pump.
SuperStart 24DCM: Group 24 / 575 CCA / flooded dual-purpose. Meets OMC minimum (Group 24M min, 27M preferred, ≥650 CCA preferred). 575 CCA below the preferred mark but adequate for warm-engine spring starts. Full match table in Battery tab.
If the plug was pushed out by freezing, the block itself may also be cracked. After reseating the plug:
Measured 2026-06-10: the plug + bore look FINE / reusable, but access is TIGHT and Sam doesn't want to pull the engine — see the install procedure below (rubber now / brass later). Plug size = 1.5" (measured 2026-06-10). Sam is ordering a 1.5" RUBBER expansion plug from Amazon (the rubber-now fix). Tracked as issue fourwinns-freezeplug-starboard-2026-06-08.
The plug + bore look reusable, but it's a tight spot and Sam isn't pulling the engine. Rubber-now / brass-later plan + the no-hammer tight-space methods:
Real fix (haul-out)Pull the drive; inspect/replace the bellows (exhaust / shift / driveshaft), reseal the transom plate with marine sealant, and address any corroded casting or wet transom. If the bellows have never been done, they're overdue maintenance anyway (they have a service life). This is THE fix. SAM-FILL: bellows kit + transom-seal parts for the OMC Cobra.
In-water stopgapsBuy time, NOT permanent: underwater-cure epoxy / marine putty (Splash-Zone-type) on a small fitting/seam seep; reseal from the INSIDE if the leak point is reachable from the bilge (a through-transom fitting/screw resealed with marine sealant); and IF the "protrusion" is a bolted PLATE (not the bellows), remove the plate and reseal the screws/holes with 3M 5200 or BoatLife Lifeseal — doable on the trailer (quick out-and-back), not fully in-water.
Keep-it-afloat / manage the waterWhat people do with a minor known leak until haul-out: make the bilge system bulletproof (Part 2 below) — a reliable auto pump + a backup pump + a reliable float + a maintained battery (or solar maintainer) + a HIGH-WATER ALARM — and fix the leak at the next haul-out.
Sam's leak video is the primary evidence — watch it to trace the drip to its origin (bellows vs plate-fitting vs casting vs transom seam). SAM-FILL: the exact entry point from the video.
Dry the bilge completely, get the boat in the water (or fill carefully on the trailer), and watch WHERE the water comes in — trace the drip back to its origin.
If it leaks only in the water → the source is below the waterline (bellows / casting / below-WL fitting — haul-out territory). If it also leaks on the trailer when you pour water at the plate → it's a plate/fitting/seam above the waterline (more likely a reseal you can do on the trailer).
UPDATE 2026-06-09 — improvingThe ORIGINAL Rule-Mate 500 is now WORKING properly (auto sensing + pumping) — so the boat has a functioning automatic bilge again. Because a pump now runs and pumps on that circuit, the power + pump path (wiring / fuse / ground) is proven OK. The SECOND RM500 runs but won't move water → an internal pump fault (not the circuit) — Sam is taking it apart to inspect. Sam also ordered a NEW bilge pump (arriving tonight) for backup/primary. SAM-FILL: second-pump inspection result.
One pump works on the same circuit, so this is pump-internal, not the circuit. Likely causes:
Inspection checklist: impeller spins freely + not cracked + tight on the shaft; intake/strainer clear; anti-airlock vent clear.
Diagnosis reference (below) — how the failing-pump issue was worked + the standard wiring/float troubleshooting + safety upgrades. The Rule-Mate-vs-Rule clarification confirmed these are Rule-Mate (auto, no float) — kept for the second pump + finishing the job.
If RULE-MATE (auto, no float)Direct-wiring is correct and it should self-cycle. Running constantly direct-wired = the internal sensor failed (replace) OR a wiring fault feeding it. Two RM pumps behaving the same = both failed (possible if old) OR a shared wiring/ground problem → check the wiring Sam touched FIRST.
If plain RULE (needs float)The "worked on float, then float-down-still-runs" history = the float switch failed/stuck/miswired; "stopped on the helm switch" = helm switch / wiring / fuse / ground fault; direct-to-battery always runs (expected — no float in that path). This fits the symptoms well → the EXTERNAL FLOAT SWITCH (+ the wiring disturbed during the electrical work) is the prime suspect. With two pumps, use the known-good one to isolate pump-vs-circuit.
Key deductionBecause two different pumps behaved identically, the fault is most likely UPSTREAM of the pump — the float switch and/or the wiring / helm switch / fuse / ground, not the pump itself. "Ran constantly with float down" = float stuck/failed/miswired (or auto + manual circuits crossed). "Stopped from the boat switch" = helm-switch / fuse / ground fault. Both point at the bilge + float wiring — retrace what the recent electrical work touched.
Read the label (Rule-Mate = auto, no float, 2-wire; plain Rule = needs a float). A plain pump typically has 3 wires: ground, manual-on (from the helm switch), and auto (through the float switch). SAM-FILL: Sam's exact model wiring.
Disconnect it and hand-test: lift it → continuity; down → open. If it reads closed when down or sticks → replace it (a common, cheap failure). This directly explains "ran constantly with the float down."
Confirm 12V at the switch, continuity through it, and a good ground. A blown fuse / corroded ground / failed switch kills the manual circuit ("stopped from the boat switch").
The "runs always" + "switch dead" combo strongly suggests a wiring error — verify the auto and manual legs aren't bridged and the float is in the right leg. Retrace the bilge + float wiring against exactly what Sam touched.
Reverse what you did last fall: close petcocks, reconnect coolant tubes. The outdrive gear oil refill is a separate task (Gear Oil tab).
The OMC 4.3L Cobra has block drain petcocks on both sides of the engine (one per bank) and exhaust manifold drains. Also typically a drain on the seawater pickup line.
Coolant tubes route raw water from outdrive up to engine. Usually clamped with hose clamps.
Running an OMC Cobra outdrive dry will destroy bearings in minutes — gear oil must be confirmed full and properly burped (no trapped air) before the drive runs in gear.
The Cobra shift type changes what oil the LOWER unit takes:
SAM-CONFIRM the shift type before filling the lower unit. (Electric-shift Type-C requirement per iboats / OMC-Cobra service references.)
Common DIY mistake: filling from the bottom drain. OEM procedure is fill from the MIDDLE port with a hand pump while leaving the top dipstick out (for air escape). Bottom-fill can trap air, which causes hydraulic lock or worse, an air bubble that melts gears under load.
Source: 1989 OMC Service Manual 0507759, Clymer 1986-1993, OMC-trained mechanics on iboats.com.
Drive must be in full down / vertical position so all oil settles to the bottom. If trim is broken, lower manually with pry bar against the trim ram, supporting safely.
Bottom drain plug should still be removed from winterization, or finger-tight if you put it back. Confirm before next step.
Top plug is the dipstick. Set aside loosely (you'll need it shortly). Leaving top open lets air escape as oil pumps in from middle port.
Once oil is at level mark (with dipstick just resting), screw dipstick all the way in. Creates the "hydraulic lock" / air lock that prevents oil from gushing out when you remove the pump.
Dipstick torque: 10-12 ft-lbs (14-16 N·m). Snug but not crushing.
Replaces the failed 2018 NAPA 7575 from DHL-001 (sulfated after winter storage with parasitic draw).
DL06067 is bolt-on with proper torque hardware. DL06070 is marine wing-nut style. For permanent installation with vibration exposure, bolt-on is more mechanically secure — won't loosen over time. Wing-nut is better for tool-free maintenance access, but for a boat serviced 1-2x/year, that's not a real benefit.
Don't start engine until you've verified battery wired correctly.
This is what killed the last battery. Run this test on the new install.
| Item | Recommendation | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Oil viscosity | SAE 25W-40 marine (preferred) OR SAE 30 (acceptable) |
Marine detergent oil. Mercury 25W-40 4-Stroke, Pennzoil Marine 25W-40, Sierra 25W-40. |
| Capacity (with filter) | ~4.5 quarts | OMC 4.3L V6 nominal. Verify level on dipstick after filling 4 qt. |
| Oil filter | OMC/Mercury 35-866340Q03 OR Sierra 18-7824 OR WIX 51394 / FRAM PH3614 |
Same filter mount as GM 4.3L automotive. Marine filter preferred (anti-drainback valve more robust). |
Run on muffs 5-10 min to warm the oil. Warm oil drains faster and carries more contaminants out. Cold drain still works, just slower and less complete.
Marine engines typically don't have an accessible gravity drain. Most boat owners extract through dipstick tube with hand pump.
Before trailering to the launch, run engine on garden hose muffs to verify everything works. Do this AFTER all other tabs.
Muffs cup over the side water intake grilles on outdrive lower unit. Seal with rubber pads. Some pressure required — muff strap or spring keeps them clamped on.
Water should exit the "pisser" tell-tale port (small visible stream from lower unit/exhaust). No stream = impeller failure or blocked intake. SHUT DOWN immediately if no stream.
| Make / model | Four Winns Freedom 190 (1989, OMC-era Freedom line: 150/170/190). NOT the modern (2022+) H-series H190 — that's a different boat; the legacy URL slug still says h190. |
| Year | 1989 model year (Dec 1988 manufacture) |
| HIN | 4WNTH065L889 |
| Length | 19 ft 0 in |
| Hull type | Fiberglass, open-bow bowrider |
| Owner | Samuel Michael Foran |
| Engine | OMC Cobra 4.3L V6 (GM-based 262 cu in, marinized ~190 hp) |
| Engine MOD | 432APRMED |
| Engine SER | T1132957 |
| Drive MOD | 985685 |
| Drive SER | T064953 (partial) |
| Production | 1986-1993 (OMC Cobra line). OMC bankruptcy 2000. |
| Current (new): | SuperStart 24DCM — Group 24, 575 CCA, 12V flooded dual-purpose marine |
| Previous (failed): | NAPA Legend 7575 (Group 75, ~Jun 2018, ~7.8 yr old, sulfated) |
| OMC spec: | BCI 24M minimum, 27M preferred. ≥650 CCA preferred. Top-post threaded. |
| Charging spec: | 13.0–14.7V at battery, engine running, 1500 RPM |
| Part | Duralast DL06067 (AutoZone SKU 95964) |
| Description | Universal top-post bolt-on, epoxy-coated, color-coded red/black |
| Quantity | 2-pack (1+ / 1-) |
| Price | ~$10.99-11.99 |
| Cable gauge (TBD) | Measured after cutting back corroded terminals. Expected: 4 AWG or 2 AWG. |
| Type | SAE 80W-90 marine gear lube (OMC Hi-Vis, Mercury Quicksilver, Sierra 18-9750) |
| Capacity | ~64 oz / 2 qt |
| Fill port | MIDDLE plug |
| Drain port | BOTTOM plug |
| Level check | TOP dipstick |
| Fill plug torque | 60-84 in-lbs (7-9 N·m) |
| Dipstick torque | 10-12 ft-lbs (14-16 N·m) |
| Type | SAE 25W-40 marine (preferred) or SAE 30 |
| Capacity | ~4.5 qt with filter |
| Filter options | OMC/Mercury 35-866340Q03, Sierra 18-7824, WIX 51394, or FRAM PH3614 |
| Alternator | Motorola/Prestolite 51 A, 12V, internal regulator |
| OMC part # | 0985465 or 0985466 |
| Mounting | 2" mounting foot, OMC Cobra 1987-1993 across 2.3L/3.0L/4.3L/5.0L/5.7L |
| Manual | Part # | Where to get |
|---|---|---|
| OMC Cobra Service Manual (1989, 1986-1993) | 0507759 | Sam has physical copy. Online: watercraftmanuals.com, scribd, eBay used. |
| OMC Cobra Parts Catalog | 0985974 | Crowley Marine, Marine Parts House (free online lookup). |
| OMC Cobra Owner's Manual | 0985996 | Sam has physical copy. |
| Clymer OMC Cobra Manual (1986-1993) | Haynes B753 | Amazon ~$30-40. Covers 2.3L-7.5L incl. 4.3L. Has wiring diagrams. |
| Seloc Marine Repair Guide for OMC Cobra (1986-1998) | Seloc 18-03404 | Sierra International, Amazon. Newer than Clymer; covers SX successor too. |
| Four Winns Freedom-series Owner's Manual (1989-era) | n/a | Hull info, not engine. Get the FREEDOM/OMC-era manual — NOT the modern "H series" manual (that's the 2022+ H190, a different boat). SAM-FILL: vintage Four Winns Freedom owner's-manual PDF source. |
None are blockers right now. Watch list for future service.
| Aftermarket | SEI Marine, Sierra Marine, GLM Marine, CDI Electronics |
| NOS / used | iboats.com, Crowley Marine, eBay marine |
| GM block parts | 4.3L V6 long-block uses standard GM automotive parts — gaskets, bearings, pistons, etc. |
| Bimini bracket clips | Broken. Generic universal bimini pole clips sized by tube diameter (NOT a Four Winns OEM part). Common 7/8" or 1" tube; ~$10 / 4-pack. SAM-FILL: measure a bimini bow/tube diameter (7/8" vs 1") before ordering. Priority: low. |
| Side vent covers | Cracked plastic louvered vents. Generic marine louvered vent sized to the cutout (~$15-30) OR Four Winns OEM via Boat Outfitters (boatoutfitters.com). SAM-FILL: vent cutout dimensions + louvered-vs-solid (measure/photo), then pick generic vs OEM. Priority: low. |
| Cranking battery (sizing) | Marine dual-purpose Group 24 or 27, ~650+ CCA / 800+ MCA (Gp 27 = more capacity if the tray fits; Gp 24 = lighter/cheaper). Gp 31 = overkill for a 4.3L runabout. OMC Cobra 4.3 manual minimum ~375 CCA / 475 MCA / 90 Ah (verify); practical floor ~550 CCA. Installed this season: SuperStart 24DCM (see Battery tab). SAM-FILL: battery tray/box dimensions (Gp 24 vs 27 fit); flooded vs AGM. |
Sources (added 2026-06-02, merged from the archived v0.1 field notes): bimini pole clips ~$10/4-pack (7/8"/1") via eBay/Amazon generic listings; side vents generic marine vent or Four Winns OEM via boatoutfitters.com; battery minimums per OMC Cobra 4.3 owner's manual; local marine-battery pricing Walmart EverStart / O'Reilly Super Start / AutoZone Duralast.
Newest first. Update this tab when work completes.
As work completes, add timeline entries. Format: date · status, title, brief detail.